How does your perception of Timothy Treadwell evolve during the film, and how is that opinion shaped by Herzog’s narration?
The first frame features Timothy Treadwell wearing sunglasses expressing himself to us, with a wild bear in the background. At first hand one assumes he is just ‘enthusiastic’ or even ‘fascinated’ by the bears (almost what David Attenborough is to nature). However there’s much more to it (which is touched upon by Herzog himself later on). However what’s evident straight away is Timothy’s desire to almost live with the bears in peace, to love them and cherish them. He speaks about ‘warriors’ and ‘death’ in a very artistic and profound way. However what he doesn’t realize is that his words are in a sense contradictory as in one moment he explains how the bears can bite and kill. He further says “I will love them and protect them but I will not die at their claws and paws; I will fight I will be strong…I will be the master”. This is because he dies at the hands of a bear, an animal that he felt he found himself in, who he felt he was protecting. Thus in this way he envisioned how he would die. Sadly the tragedy of this story is that his death was one he didn’t expect, certainly in the way that it happened in anyway. Who knew the animals he was protecting would later kill him. Was this a sign that an animals ‘eden’ should never interrupted by man? Surely Timothy knew that there would always be the risk of the animals turning against him in fright or anger?
In particular, Herzog focuses on Timothy’s character and his thought processes. However upon introducing himself he explains how he finds Timothy’s footage to include: “Human ecstasy and darkest inner turmoil”. This is just another example of the ‘demons’, which were ‘consuming’ Timothy in his daily life. One thing, which stayed put, was his love and devotion to the bears. It is this, which Herzog finds ‘fascinating’ and remarkable in its self, further brought on by Timothy’s exuberant nature and theatrical style in presenting himself to the bears and his camera.
What really moved me was the evident struggle that Timothy was facing with himself and humanity too. For example in one scene he calls upon the God’s of different faiths to bring rain into the grizzly maze for the bears. In this exact moment we see his sheer desire and need for it. It’s in this moment where we truly see that Timothy’s ‘struggle’ truly lies in himself. This is further apparent when he curses at the ‘park services’ towards the end of the documentary. It’s here that Herzog draws light on this in a very analytical way. He clarifies almost immediately that “we” won’t cross this line that Treadwell has just done. What he’s talking about is how Treadwell straight away starts to attack the park services for their ‘park restrictions’, who Treadwell worked for, for 13 years.
Treadwell further begins to get very agitated and angry whilst mentioning the park services. Considering that he instigates how they don’t protect the animals and how he’s the only one doing something, when this is not true. Herzog says here: “It’s clear to see that the park services are not Treadwell’s real enemy, there’s a larger more implacable adversary out there; the peoples world and civilization.” Herzog then mentions ‘madness’ associating it with Treadwell’s behavior. Saying that he’s only seen this behavior from actors on a film set. He then states how Treadwell’s not an actor as he’s a filmmaker, thus in a way he s fighting civilization itself.
In conclusion my opinion of Treadwell is shaped by Herzog, but only ever so slightly. This is because I believe Herzog ‘observes’ Treadwell in a very incandescent and mature way. He believes things opposite to Treadwell, however he doesn’t cut Treadwell off completely as he see’s Treadwell is fighting demons within himself. Thus is ‘understanding’ because of this (to an extent).
One thing, which is completely true, however is Treadwell’s blindness to the ‘animal order’. For example in one instance Treadwell is shocked when his pet fox dies by the hands of a bear. Whilst Herzog isn’t as it’s the natural order of things (however brutal this may be). Thus in this way I fully agree with Herzog as he differs with Treadwell as he outlines that in nature there are predators. He believes the common denominator of the universe not to be harmony but to be chaos and hostility and murder (as mentioned in his narration). Thus Herzog is stating the reality of the ‘animal order’, one that Timothy didn’t want to believe. Thus it’s at the end of the documentary that we come to understand that Treadwell used the bears as an ‘escape’. He wanted to (in some ways) protect and control their ‘land’. However I personally believe there are some borders man should not cross. In this case man should not interrupt an animals ‘land’ as he inexplicably interrupts an animals senses. Giving them initial shock at their first encounter with a human (who is extremely close to them).
References:
Image 1 (Google Images):
Image: https://uk.movieposter.com/poster/MPW-17096/Grizzly_Man.html (accessed 19/12/15)
Excerpts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8MjDyfcMmU
Source: YouTube/Grizzly Man Documentary/ Directed by: Werner Herzog/2005- Channel: StuOh/July 2012/Education
You must be logged in to post a comment.